Does HJR-192 Discharge Debt? What the Courts Said
No. Courts across the country have rejected HJR-192, "accepted for value," and Treasury "bill of exchange" payments. A debt "paid" this way stays unpaid, and borrowers who relied on it have lost foreclosure cases.
The claim
Promoters say that when the U.S. left the gold standard in 1933, debts could no longer be paid with real money. They say every person has a secret Treasury account. Stamping a bill "accepted for value," or sending a "bill of exchange" drawn on that account, supposedly pays the debt, and a creditor who refuses it supposedly discharges the debt.
What HJR-192 actually did
House Joint Resolution 192, passed June 5, 1933, voided "gold clauses" in contracts and made U.S. coins and currency legal tender for all debts. It's codified at 31 U.S.C. § 5118. A federal court summed it up as having "provided for the suspension of the gold standard." It created no personal Treasury accounts. Federal Reserve notes remain legal tender for all debts (31 U.S.C. § 5103).
What courts decided
| Case | Court and year | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Bryant v. Washington Mutual Bank, 524 F. Supp. 2d 753 | Federal court, W.D. Virginia, 2007 | A borrower tendered a $244,663.79 "bill of exchange" drawn on a Treasury account to stop foreclosure. Case dismissed with prejudice: the document had no legal validity as payment. |
| In re Hill | Bankruptcy court, E.D. Tennessee, 2015 | Debtors argued their Treasury bill of exchange paid their debts. The court held it was not legal tender and not an acceptable payment. |
| U.S. Bank N.A. v. Phillips, 852 N.E.2d 380 | Illinois Court of Appeals, 2006 | A bill of exchange drawn on a Treasury account is not a negotiable instrument that discharges a debt (as described in In re Hill). |
| McElroy v. Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corp., 134 Cal. App. 4th 388 | California Court of Appeal, 2005 | A California decision rejecting the same kind of payment (cited in In re Hill). |
| McLaughlin v. CitiMortgage, 726 F. Supp. 2d 201 | Federal court, D. Connecticut, 2010 | Rejected the theory (cited in In re Hill). |
| Thompson v. Thompson | Federal court, E.D. Michigan, 2011 | A motion "pursuant to House Joint Resolution 192" was denied. The court said the resolution only suspended the gold standard. |
| Knapp v. Wings | Federal court, D. Minnesota, 2024 | The "vapor money" theory and "special indorsement" of loan notes were held frivolous. The borrower was barred from filing more suits without court permission. |
The Treasury's own position
As quoted by the court in In re Hill, the Treasury Department has said that "all these Bills of Exchange drawn on the U.S. Treasury are worthless."
What actually works instead
- Debt collectors: Dispute the debt in writing within 30 days. The collector must then verify it before collecting (15 U.S.C. § 1692g).
- Mortgages: Send your servicer a qualified written request, ask about loss mitigation and modification, and talk to a free HUD-approved housing counselor.
- Too much debt: Negotiate a settlement, use a nonprofit credit counselor, or talk with a bankruptcy attorney about your options.
← Back to the JAG Legal Library
Have a question about a debt or contract?
Book a Consultation or call 831-316-6032.
General education, not legal or tax advice. JAG Consultants is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed attorney or CPA.